Accreditation regulations will extend federal power and require ideological review

Photo by cottenbro

The Education Department finalized its overhaul of accreditation regulations on October 30, 2026; if implemented, they will take effect on July 1, 2027. These regulations will give Washington unprecedented leverage over the independent bodies that vouch for college quality. In the process, they may chill campus speech, discourage sex- and race-conscious programs, and pressure schools to cut valuable but lower-paying areas of study.

Contact your representatives and senators and urge them to take steps to block this change.

The Higher Education Act states explicitly that "[n]othing in this Act shall be construed to permit the Secretary [of Education] to establish criteria for accrediting agencies or associations that are not required by this section . . . to establish any criteria that specifies, defines, or prescribes the standards that accrediting agencies or associations shall use to assess any institution’s success with respect to student achievement."

But the new regulations introduce more than 20 new mandates for accrediting bodies that overstep the Education Department's statutory authority, according to the American Council on Education. Critics contend that the rule not only injects political and ideological considerations into what is legally required to be an independent, nonpartisan process, but also forces accreditors to act as federal compliance enforcers rather than peer evaluators of educational quality.

Under the new regulations, when evaluating colleges and universities, accreditors are required to:

  • Evaluate policies governing academic freedom and intellectual diversity.

  • Assess student outcomes using metrics such as post-graduation earnings.

  • Verify compliance with federal civil rights laws, while refraining from imposing their own diversity, equity, and inclusion mandates.

Requiring accreditors to judge campus policies on intellectual diversity and academic freedom pushes them into unfamiliar territory: scrutinizing the classroom and curriculum itself. Because the regulation offers no clear metric for what constitutes "intellectual diversity," critics warn that evaluations could become subjective and politically driven. Facing the risk of losing federal aid eligibility, university administrators may feel pressured to impose informal ideological quotas on faculty recruitment and course readings. Potentially, this could compel faculty to treat debunked claims on par with peer-reviewed research.

“Turning accreditors into legal compliance officers does not strengthen accreditation. It changes its purpose,” wrote Nasser Paydar, president of the Council for Higher Education Accreditation.

None of this improves educational institutions; all of it undermines education.

Previous
Previous

2026 midterm elections: What this means for academic freedom

Next
Next

Act before December 11 to stop OMB's threat to U.S. research