On November 2, 2026, U.S. District Judge Myong Joun in Boston dismissed the Department of Justice's invasive lawsuit demanding five years of applicant-level records from Harvard — a vital victory for due process, student privacy, and University autonomy.
As reported by The Harvard Crimson, the agency bypassed required legal procedures to demand individual files, including confidential admissions ratings, linked test scores and demographics, and personal application essays. Such granular data could strip away anonymity; have a chilling effect on students' willingness to speak openly about their identities, backgrounds, and beliefs; and expose young people to government surveillance and antidemocratic retaliation.
In litigation beginning on February 13, the Department of Justice filed a complaint seeking “applicant-level” admissions data. The DOJ claimed it needed “applicant-level data to determine whether Harvard is complying with Title VI and the Supreme Court’s ruling” in Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard, the 2023 Supreme Court case eliminating the consideration of race in admissions decisions.
However, this may run afoul of privacy laws, specifically the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act. This federal law restricts the sharing of records that could be used to identify an individual student.
Additionally, Harvard's lawyers countered that the case was filed in retaliation because the University has refused to comply with demands to change its governance, hiring and academic programs, according to reporting in Reuters.
The case was decided procedural grounds, so If it chooses, the government can amend the lawsuit and submit the case once again.
This ruling follows a string of legal decisions in favor of Harvard on research funding, international students, and alleged failure to protect Jewish students. It also vindicates Crimson Courage’s February call in The Guardian urging Harvard to stand firm and "keep personal applicant data confidential to protect students from federal government retaliation."